Listen on: Spotify · Apple Podcasts · Amazon Music · iHeart · Pandora · Pocket Casts · Overcast · Castbox · TuneIn · Deezer · RSS feed
This week on Hot Off the Press, Randy Rohde (The News Guy) sat down with Lior Manelis of BlckPanda Creative, a web design and SEO agency (yes, the missing “a” is on purpose). They covered why ranking in the map pack isn’t the same as getting chosen, why old-school SEO still carries the load in the AI era, how ads work better with a human face, and how Lior is automating his agency with APIs.
Ranking isn’t the same as getting chosen
Lior recently had a client sitting in the top three of the map pack who wasn’t getting calls. The reason: of the three businesses shown, he had the fewest reviews. Lior’s read is that human behavior favors the business that looks more trustworthy, so reviews are a trust signal for people, not just a ranking input.
Randy added a useful counterpoint. The old theory said you needed 20 to 30 reviews to appear in the map pack, but some of his own lead gen sites rank in the top three with one, two or three reviews. Reviews may not be a hard ranking gate, but they matter for conversion.
Review velocity beats catching up
Lior tells clients it’s not about catching up, it’s about consistency. Getting one or two reviews a week can eventually put you above a competitor with more total reviews. He sees that steady stream as a better signal to Google than a big burst followed by silence. Randy pointed to Darren Shaw, who has also talked about review velocity and frequency.
Randy’s practical tip, which he gave a restaurant that had opened two weeks earlier: print the Google Business Profile review QR code and put it right on the counter, in the little stands next to the salt and pepper shakers.
Old-school SEO still carries the load
Lior’s view is that SEO is “old school SEO done properly,” with no magic button, and that tools only help once the foundation is solid. His local strategy hasn’t changed in two or three years. He does the on-page work right, then backs it with off-page support like press releases, backlinks and niche edits. Randy noted the same fundamentals still lend themselves to AI visibility.
- Niche edits: Lior calls them “touch and go” and treats them as a supplement. He suggests a single-variable test to see whether they do anything.
- Directories: Lior builds his own and uses them as tier-one sources to send backlinks to. He says they’ve replaced some of the links he used to build.
Ads work better with a human face
Randy runs Meta ads (Facebook and Instagram) as both static images and video. The video ads perform best when he’s on camera saying, in effect, “we’re real, talk to us.” His ads run about 30 to 40 seconds. He’s also found that landing pages convert better than Meta lead forms, even though forms bring in more submissions.
Lior has a “passionate dislike” for ads. His own DIY Meta attempt, an offer to meet locally and audit a website face to face, was a “miserable failure.” He admits it could have been the messaging, budget or audience. Both agreed the next try could be a short 15 to 20 second reel, or a camera clip in place of his ElevenLabs voice clone.
Automating an agency with APIs
Lior is building agency automation on APIs. His stack includes Turbo Subdomains, a set of Google APIs, MCP Scraper, Railway, GitHub, 1Password and AWS. Here is what he has done so far:
- Automated Turbo Subdomains through its API. He owns nine domains, each with a 1,000-subdomain package, so he can run a campaign across all nine from a few clicks.
- Canceled Ahrefs and built his own keyword tools with Data for SEO. He says it gives him what he needs, though he concedes some of its data, like keyword tracking, isn’t great.
- Added MCP Scraper, where he has used 800,000 credits in a month for research.
His goal is a fully automated flow of onboarding, research, on-page and off-page work, with the only manual step being approval of the page writing. Randy is more cautious. He has 14 team members and human writers and editors, and he doesn’t want to bet his business on automating press release content. Lior agreed that press releases need a human review.
Rapid-fire round
- Desert-island SEO tool: Search Console.
- Feature to retire: the WordPress slider. Removing one from a client’s hero section took their GTmetrix grade from an E to an A.
- Agency life as a movie: The Matrix.
- Why a panda: his partner Kyle’s cat is named Panda.
Key takeaways
- A top-three map pack spot doesn’t guarantee calls. The business with the fewest reviews may get skipped.
- Aim for one or two reviews a week instead of a burst and then silence.
- Put your review QR code where customers can’t miss it.
- Do on-page SEO properly first, then support it with press releases, backlinks and directories.
- Video ads with a real person on camera work well, and landing pages convert better than lead forms.
- APIs can replace pricey tools and speed up an agency, but quality content still needs human eyes.
Frequently asked questions
Why am I in the top three of the Google map pack but not getting calls?
Lior Manelis of BlckPanda Creative had a client in exactly this spot. He had the fewest reviews of the three businesses shown, and people tend to pick the one that looks more trustworthy. Reviews work as a trust signal for humans, not just a ranking input.
How many Google reviews should a local business get per week?
Lior tells clients to aim for one or two reviews a week. He says that consistency (velocity) can eventually put you above a competitor with more total reviews, and it sends a better signal than a big burst followed by silence.
Does old-school SEO still matter for AI search?
According to Lior and Randy Rohde, yes. Lior says SEO is old-school SEO done properly, and Randy noted that fundamentals still help AI visibility. That means on-page work first, then off-page support like press releases, backlinks and directories.
Do landing pages or Meta lead forms convert better?
Randy Rohde found that landing pages convert better than Meta lead forms. Forms bring in more submissions, but far fewer of them convert into customers.
Can you automate an SEO agency with APIs?
Lior Manelis is doing it with APIs from Turbo Subdomains, Google and MCP Scraper, hosted on Railway and GitHub. It has let him cancel Ahrefs and build his own keyword tools. Randy Rohde cautions that press release quality still needs a human review.
Want your news to show up in Google and AI answers?
Hot Off the Press is brought to you by The News Guy: press releases that get your business in front of journalists, search engines and AI answer engines. Book a free 15-minute consultation.
More episodes: Hot Off The Press podcast. See you in the headlines.